This web site is designed for 800 x 600 screens with 16 bit resolutions.
It's best viewed with
Click Here To Start.
Aerodynamic Center Lateral Stability
Lateral stability refers to stability around
the longitudinal axis. It is sometimes called roll stability, although
this is a misnomer.
Rolling
Moments and Roll Damping
When the aircraft is flying in straight flight (no slip)
with the ailerons neutral both wings produce the same amount
of lift. This is true because both wings are at the same angle
of attack and flying at the same velocity.
If the pilot deflects the ailerons then one wing will produce
more lift than the other (because it now has more camber.)
This causes a rolling moment. The aircraft will begin to roll
and will continue to roll, faster and faster, as long as one
wing produces more lift than the other.
As the aircraft rolls the angle of attack of the down going
wing increases and the angle of attack of the up-going wing
decreases. Before long the lift difference between the wings
will disappear. Once the lift from both wings is the same
a constant rate of roll will be established (the more the
ailerons are deflected the higher the roll rate will be.)
If the pilot returns the ailerons to neutral there will once
again be a difference in lift between the wings with the down
going wing being at a greater angle of attack. This condition
will cause a roll rate in the opposite direction until the
roll stops. At that point both wings are producing the same
amount of lift and the angle of bank will remain constant.
The tendency for the roll rate to become constant
(i.e. roll moment to become zero) is called roll damping. This helps
to establish lateral stability but it is not enough. At most roll
damping would be expected to produce neutral lateral stability.
Roll
Moments Induced by Yaw
If a pilot steps on a rudder pedal causing the aircraft to yaw
one wing will advance and the other will retreat. The faster moving
wing produce more lift than the other which will cause a roll in
the same direction as the yaw. This will be exaggerated by wing
dihedral which we will discuss below.
Lateral Stability
Most light aircraft display approximately neutral lateral static
stability. In other words when rolled into a given bank and released
the aircraft remains more or less at that angle of bank.
If the aircraft rolled back to zero bank by itself we would say
it had positive static lateral stability. If it rolled further,
into a steeper bank we would say it was displaying negative static
lateral stability.
Most light aircraft if left with no pilot input will eventually
roll into a steeper turn, usually entering a spiral dive. This means
that most aircraft exhibit negative dynamic lateral stability. Despite
this they can be flown quite well, except they require considerable
attention when flying in IMC conditions.
As indicated above lateral stability and directional stability
are closely linked. If an aircraft has a lot of directional stability
(most do) it tends to become unstable laterally. This is because
the bank angle starts the aircraft turning, which speeds
up the wing on the outside of the turn (high wing.) The faster
wing produces more lift, which rolls the aircraft into a
steeper bank.
All aircraft will exhibit negative lateral static stability, as
describe above, unless the designer adds some combination of the
design features listed below to combat the effect described above.
Dihedral
High Wings
Swept Wings
Dihedral
Dihedral is the most common design feature
used to increase the lateral stability. The movie below shows
how dihedral works.
In order to understand dihedral you must realize that the side
force created by a bank angle will pull the aircraft sideways through
the air. In other words it will cause the aircraft to slip.
As mentioned above the aircraft will slip once it
enters a banked attitude. However, the directional stability will
quickly turn the aircraft into this new relative wind (as discussed
on the previous page.) As a result the slip will quickly disappear
and the dihedral effect will be eliminated.
High
Wing Effect
Aircraft with high wings (wings which are above the
c of g) will have more lateral stability than aircraft which have
low wings (below the c of g.) This is often referred to as the pendulum
effect. Essentially the mass of the aircraft tends to swing back
under the wing when disturbed laterally. Conversely the low wing
aircraft is unstable laterally, just as a pendulum would be if you
balanced it upside down. The movie below demonstrates this effect.
Swept
wings
Swept wings are one of the most effective ways of
increasing lateral stability. However, they are usually only used
on high speed jet aircraft. Therefore, this effect is reserved only
for those lucky enough to fly a jet.
Just as with the dihedral effect, the swept wing affects
lateral stability because the aircraft tends to slip initially one
banked. The movie below shows how the slip angle changes the relative
sweep of the two wings. This in turn changes the amount of lift
each wing produces.
Earlier we learned that
the slope of the CL vs. Angle of Attack curve for
a swept wing aircraft is shallower than that of a straight
winged aircraft. As a result, if two wings are at the same
angle of attack the straighter wing will produce more lift
and the swept wing will produce less lift.
Dutch Roll
Many swept wing aircraft suffer a dynamic instability
problem known as Dutch Roll.
Dutch roll happens when the aircraft has relatively
strong static lateral stability (usually due to the swept wings)
and somewhat weak directional stability (relatively.) In a Dutch
roll the aircraft begins to yaw due to a gust or other input. The
yaw is slow damping out so the aircraft begins to roll before the
yaw is stopped (due to the increased speed of the advancing wing
and the increased lift due to the swept wing effect.)
By the time the yaw stops and begins to swing back
toward zero slip the aircraft has developed a considerable roll
rate and due to momentum plus the slip angle the aircraft continues
to roll even once the nose has begun returning to the original slip
angle.
Eventually the yaw overshoots the zero slip angle
causing the wings to begin rolling back in the opposite direction.
The whole procedure repeats, sometimes with large
motions, sometimes witch just a small churning motion. Like
all dynamic stability problems, Dutch roll is much worse at high
altitudes where the air is less dense.
Dutch roll is almost certain to happen in a jet aircraft
is the Yaw dampener is turned off at high altitude. Therefore, the
first thing to check if an aircraft begins to exhibit Dutch roll
is that the Yaw Dampener is on. The pilot should then try to minimize
the yawing oscillations by blocking the rudder pedals (i.e. hold
the rudder pedals in the neutral position.) Next apply aileron (spoiler)
control opposite to the roll. The best technique to use is short
jabs of ailerons applied opposite to the roll. Try to give one quick
jab on each cycle (i.e. turn the wheel toward the rising wing, then
return it to neutral.) Finally accelerate to a higher speed, where
directional stability will be better, or descend into more dense
air, for the same reason.
The movie below shows graphically what a steady Dutch
roll looks like. However, it is critical to realize that Dutch rolls
are often dynamically divergent. In other words in this movie the
Dutch roll is exhibiting neutral dynamic stability, but it may well
be negative dynamic stability in a given aircraft (at certain
speed and air densities.)
Reducing
Lateral Stability
The
Dutch Roll tendency described above is exacerbated when an aircraft
has too much lateral stability. Generally pilots prefer to fly aircraft
which exhibit neutral static lateral stability, or very slightly
positive.
As a result aircraft with both swept and high wings
often are too stable. This can be "fixed" by incorporating
anhedral (negative dihedral.) The BAE-146 to the left is an example
of an aircraft with anhedral.